AI Litigation Case Analysis for PI Firms
· TrialBase
AI litigation case analysis is a first read of one plaintiff file, not a verdict and not a chat answer. The team uploads the pleadings, the crash report, the records, the bills, and the transcripts they already have. The draft comes back with the posture, the parties, the proof, and the gaps, and every sentence points at a page. A lawyer opens those pages before anyone treats the draft as case work.
Start free and run a case summary on your own file
A managing partner at a 2 to 25 lawyer plaintiff firm does not need another essay about artificial intelligence. The case manager already has a box of PDFs. Both of them need to see the file in one sitting, catch what is missing, and decide what the next draft may say.
That is the job of this page. It walks one rear-end file from upload to a checked analysis. It does not rank vendors. It does not teach a medical chronology or a governance policy. Those jobs already have their own guides, linked where they help.
What AI litigation case analysis is for
On a plaintiff personal injury file, the first useful question is simple. What does this record actually say, and what is still missing? AI litigation case analysis answers that question from the documents in the matter. It is not a prediction of the verdict. It is not a damages number the firm did not calculate. It is a cited snapshot a lawyer can argue with.
TrialBase is built for that snapshot. The about page describes the product as attorney-built software that turns unstructured case materials into drafts, from intake through discovery and into trial. Every output is meant to support judgment, not replace it, and each fact is linked back to the source. FastTrack actions are the named jobs that finish a slice of that grind in minutes. Case Summary is the slice this article uses as the first pass.
Three inputs get confused in a demo, and only one of them is an analysis of the case.
- A pasted question. A lawyer drops a paragraph into a public chat box. The answer is smooth. It has never seen the MRI, the bill, or the police report.
- A single-task summary. One tool reads the records and returns a chronology, or a demand, and then stops. The rest of the file still lives somewhere else.
- A full-file pass. The firm uploads the matter once. The draft states posture, parties, claims, defenses, and open items, and each line cites a page in that upload.
The third one is what a plaintiff team can hand to a partner on a Monday. The first one is a writing aid. The second one is useful later, after someone has checked that the file is complete enough to summarize. If the search you started with was "which product should we buy," use the buying comparison for plaintiff firms instead. Stay here if you want the working method on one file.
Who does the work, and who may rely on it
In a small plaintiff firm the pain shows up with the case manager or the litigation paralegal. They are the people still building the story by hand from a discharge summary, a physical therapy log, and a stack of bills. The managing partner or founding attorney owns the risk. Those two should run the first file together. The case manager picks the matter and checks that the upload is the real chart. The lawyer decides what the draft is allowed to support.
Write the refusal list before the first upload. A short list that fits this firm looks like this.
- No client record goes into a tool that trains shared models on firm uploads.
- No sentence is treated as a fact until a lawyer has opened the cited page and found the quoted line.
- No draft goes to a client, an adjuster, or a court until a lawyer has edited it.
- No second copy of the chart. One upload should feed the summary, the demand, and the discovery that follows.
- No analysis of a file the firm has not actually received. A vendor sample is not your case.
The American Bar Association put the duty in writing on July 29, 2024. Formal Opinion 512 says lawyers who use generative AI still owe competence, confidentiality, communication, and reasonable fees. On confidentiality, the lawyer must protect information relating to the representation unless the client gives informed consent. The opinion itself is ABA Formal Opinion 512 (PDF).
That opinion is why a smooth paragraph is not the test. If the tool cannot show the page, the lawyer cannot do the review. Read the citation. Notice what the page does not say. Do not let the draft fill that silence.
What goes into the first upload
The first pass is only as honest as the pile you give it. For a typical auto case, upload the documents the team already trusts, not a cleaned sample. TrialBase's case summary takes that pile: pleadings, records, bills, discovery, transcripts, photos, and correspondence. Storage is free, and the read includes audio and video when those are in the matter.
Use this as the minimum set for a rear-end or intersection file. Leave a document out only when you do not have it, and write that absence down. An analysis that pretends a missing MRI is in the file will invent a gap you cannot see.
| Document | Why the first pass needs it | What a missing copy usually means |
|---|---|---|
| Complaint or intake sheet. | It names the parties, the date, and the claims. | The draft will guess posture from a record. |
| Police or crash report. | It states the scene, the citation, and the witnesses. | Liability lines will lean on the patient's history. |
| Emergency and imaging records. | They anchor the first diagnosis and the study. | A later chronology will treat a referral as the study. |
| Treatment notes and bills. | They show the course of care and the figures. | Specials become a round number with no provider. |
| Prior records already in hand. | They let the pass see a preexisting condition. | The draft will treat the crash as the start of every symptom. |
Do not upload a public sample, a redacted marketing PDF, or a transcript from another matter. The point of the first pass is to find out what this file supports. A clean demo hides the Monday-morning problems: a rotated scan, a bill with no matching note, a witness named once.
Label the upload with the matter name the firm already uses. If two clients share a collision, keep their files apart. A combined upload will cite the wrong person's bill, and the citation will look perfect because the page really does contain that number. It is just the wrong person's number.
A worked file, from upload to a checked pass
The illustration below is a teaching file, not a TrialBase matter and not a result. Call the plaintiff Ms. Alvarez. She was stopped at a light. A commercial driver rear-ended her. The firm has the complaint, the crash report, the emergency note, one MRI, twenty-four physical therapy visits, and the bills for those providers. It does not yet have the defendant's driver log, and the emergency note mentions an imaging center whose report is not in the folder. That is a normal plaintiff file. It is not a clean one.
The case manager uploads that set once. The first draft answers the questions a partner asks before staffing the case. Where does the matter stand? Who are the parties? What is claimed, and what is defended? Which facts of liability and of harm does the record actually state?
TrialBase's own description of that draft is posture, parties, claims, defenses, and key facts, each one cited to the page it came from. A sample on the feature page uses a collision report and a complaint. Yours should cite your pages, not that sample.
Read the draft in four passes. Do not edit yet. The first pass is a map, not a rewrite.
- Posture. Confirm the draft says the complaint is filed and written discovery is open only if those pages say so. If the file is still pre-suit, the draft should say that, not "litigation."
- Parties. Match every named defendant to the complaint and the crash report. A carrier mentioned in a letter is not automatically a party.
- Proof. Open the citation behind the liability sentence and the citation behind the injury sentence. The page has to contain the fact, not a nearby fact.
- Open items. Look for the driver log and the missing imaging report. If the draft does not list them, the pass is incomplete even if the prose is clean.
On the Alvarez illustration, a sound first pass says the crash report cites the commercial driver. The emergency note records neck pain after the collision. The MRI report in the file describes a disc finding.
It also says the driver log is not in the upload, and the imaging study named in the discharge note has no matching report. It does not say the case is "strong." It does not pick a settlement number. Strength and numbers are lawyer judgments made after the citations check out.
Timebox the lawyer's read. On a file of this size, opening three citations and one missing-record call should take less than half an hour. If it takes longer, the draft is too long or the citations are vague. Send it back. Do not "fix" a vague citation by trusting the sentence.
How to check a citation before you trust the sentence
A citation is a claim that a specific page says a specific thing. Treat it like a deposition cite. You would not read "the witness admitted fault" and skip the line. Do not read "the report cites the driver" and skip the page.
Use a three-page spot check on every first pass, then a wider check when any of the three fails. Pick the pages yourself. Do not let the draft choose only its best lines.
- One liability page. Open the crash report page cited for the signal, the point of impact, or the citation issued at the scene. The sentence in the draft should not add speed, distance, or fault the page does not state.
- One medical page. Open the imaging or emergency page cited for the diagnosis. "Neck pain" is not "herniation." "Disc protrusion" is not "surgery recommended" unless that page says so.
- One money page. Open the bill or ledger cited for a figure. The amount, the provider, and the date should match. A summed "medical specials" line is acceptable only when each piece is still cited.
Fail the sentence, not the whole tool, when a citation is wrong. Mark it, and look at two more citations of the same type. One wrong page can be a bad quote. Three wrong pages means this draft is not ready to feed a demand or a discovery set. The lawyer writes the correction in the draft. The case manager does not silently patch the PDF to match the sentence.
Also check the negative. A page that is silent is not support. If the draft says there was no prior neck treatment, the cited page has to say that, or the draft has to say the file does not contain prior records. Silence is how a plaintiff analysis overstates a case. Formal Opinion 512's competence point lands right there. The lawyer has to understand what the tool did with the file, including what it filled in.
Keep a one-line log for the matter. "Checked crash report page 2, MRI page 1, and the therapy bill. Driver log still missing. Draft may be used for internal staffing only." That log is what a later lawyer needs when the demand goes out months from now. It is also what you want if a client asks what the software did.
What the analysis may support, and what it must not
A checked pass is allowed to do a short list of jobs. It may brief the partner who has not opened the file. It may tell the case manager which records to order next. It may become the starting point for a later draft, after a lawyer has said the citations hold. It is not allowed to do the jobs below, even when the prose sounds sure.
- It may not value the case. A range, a "likely settlement," or a comparison to other matters is a lawyer's opinion, and this pass did not ask for one.
- It may not decide liability the crash report does not support. "At fault" is a conclusion. "Cited for failure to stop" is a fact, if that page says it.
- It may not tell the client the firm will win, or send the client a case score. Clients should not see an unedited model draft.
- It may not fill a medical opinion. Causation language stays at what the records say. The separate guide on medical evidence and causation is the place to do that analysis. Do not shortcut it inside the first pass.
- It may not invent a missing record. If the imaging report is not in the folder, the honest line is that it is missing.
The completeness check is the natural second job, and it is a different job from the summary. TrialBase's review for completeness reads the file for gaps. A provider named in a discharge note may have no chart. A witness in the police report may never have been deposed. A bill may have no matching record.
Each finding is supposed to cite the page that raised it. On the Alvarez illustration, that review should surface the missing imaging report and the driver log. It should not also try to write the demand.
When the firm is ready for the chronology itself, use the guide that already owns that method, how to build a medical chronology. The medical summary product reads the records and bills into a table or paragraphs, by date or by provider, with a citation on each entry. That is the next work product. It is not a second copy of this analysis.
How one checked file feeds the next draft
The reason to upload once is so the next draft has to live with the same pages. After the lawyer signs the spot check, the case manager can point the same file at the work the case actually needs next. For many plaintiff matters that next piece is a demand, a set of discovery, or a note on what is still missing. It is not a new upload and not a new chat.
Keep the handoff narrow. The demand draft should pull facts and figures that already survived the spot check, and it should cite the same pages. TrialBase's demand flow drafts from the file, with a citation behind each fact and figure, and leaves a draft to review rather than a form to fill.
Do not treat this article as the demand guide. If you are choosing demand software, the demand letter software page owns that question. If you are choosing discovery tools, use AI discovery drafting. The rule from this page still applies. A lawyer opens the citations before the draft is served or sent.
A practical sequence for the Alvarez file, after the first pass checks out, looks like this.
- Order the missing imaging report and ask for the driver log. The analysis named them. The case manager now has a list, not a hunch.
- Build the chronology from the records in hand, and update it when the missing report arrives. Do not freeze the first chronology as if the file were complete.
- Draft the demand only after the specials tie to bills a lawyer has opened. A figure with no page is not ready for an adjuster.
- Aim discovery at the gaps, not at a generic set. Requests should ask for the log and the witnesses the report already names.
- Stop and re-read if a later draft cites a page the first pass marked wrong. That is a sign the file and the draft have drifted apart.
This sequence is not a firm-wide rollout. The implementation checklist for plaintiff firms covers owners, training, and go-live. The document review workflow covers who is assigned which stack and what the attorney receives at the end of a review. Use those pages when the question is staffing. Use this page when the question is what the analysis of one file is allowed to say.
Where the file is allowed to go
Before the first client PDF is uploaded, read the security page the way you would read a vendor's answer. TrialBase's security page says processing runs in private, network-isolated environments, and that firm data is not used to train shared models. It says data is encrypted in transit and at rest.
The same page says TrialBase is HIPAA compliant, and it points to independently audited SOC 2 Type II controls for security, availability, and confidentiality. Quote the page. Do not add a certification level it does not state. Do not describe those controls as a promise about one matter.
The about page makes the same privacy point in product language. TrialBase is engineered for the confidentiality standards of litigation, and the infrastructure is meant to protect client data from intake through trial. That is the claim to test, not a slogan to repeat in a demand. If the firm wants a written governance rule for who may upload what, that is a different document. The AI governance policy guide is the place to write it. Do not bury a policy inside a case analysis.
Two practical rules follow from Opinion 512 and from that security page. Do not paste a client's records into a general chat tool to "compare" the drafts. Do not upload a file to a product whose security page will not say whether uploads train a shared model. If you cannot find that sentence, you do not yet have informed consent to give, and you should not upload.
What a small firm should notice about cost
Price should not decide whether a citation is true. It does decide whether a 2 to 25 lawyer plaintiff firm can try the method on a real file without buying a seat for everyone.
On the TrialBase homepage, pricing is pay as you go. There is no seat fee and no subscription. Everyone at the firm can have an account. You pay for the work the product does, and each charge is itemized by case so it can be billed to the matter. Document storage is free.
The public try-it page says a firm can claim $50 in free credit to start. It also says there is no subscription and no contract, and that uploads are not used to train AI.
Read those lines on the homepage and on the try-it page before you repeat them. Do not add a credit expiration, a usage minimum, or a bonus the current page does not state. Do not treat an illustration in a different article as this product's rate. The $769 deposition example lives on the deposition guides, not here, and this article is not a deposition-cost page.
A useful first month is one real file, not a tour of every work product. Upload the Alvarez-style matter you actually have. Run the summary. Do the three-page spot check. If the citations hold, run the completeness review on that same file. Stop there. You will know whether the draft saves the case manager a morning, and you will know it from your own pages. If the citations fail, you have a reason to walk away that does not depend on a feature list.
The homepage also offers a 30-minute demo on a live case, from upload to a cited first draft. That is optional. A firm that would rather not put a client file on a call can use the free credit instead, on a file the lawyer has already cleared. Either way, open the page behind the sentence.
Mistakes that make the first pass useless
Most bad analyses fail before the model does anything clever. The file was wrong, the question was wrong, or nobody opened a page. Watch for these, in this order.
- Uploading a vendor sample and calling it a pilot. You learned the sample, not your chart.
- Asking for a case value in the first prompt. You will get a number. You will not get a cited file read.
- Skipping prior records because they "complicate" the story. They are the story an adjuster will tell.
- Letting a clean paragraph override a contradictory bill. The bill is the fact. The paragraph is a draft.
- Sending the draft to the client to show that the firm is modern. The client needs the lawyer's advice, not the unedited pass.
- Opening a second tool for the chronology before the gaps are listed. You will summarize an incomplete file and then trust it.
- Treating a wrong citation as a wording nit. A wrong page means the sentence is unsupported. Fix the sentence or cut it.
If the first file is a mass of scanned photos, say so in the log. A hard file is a better test than a short, typed report. Note how many pages failed to read. A citation a lawyer could open is the result, not the speed of the draft.
Firms comparing tools for discovery and trial prep should use the legal AI tools guide for personal injury lawyers. Firms choosing a whole stack should use how to choose AI for a personal injury firm. This page assumes you are already in the file.
A one-file test for this week
Pick one open plaintiff matter with a crash report, one imaging study, and a bill you have already questioned. Do not pick the firm's best case. Do not pick a case with a hearing this week. You want a file where a wrong sentence is cheap to catch.
- Write the refusal list at the top of this article on a sticky note, including the ban on shared-model training.
- Upload only the documents you listed in the table. Record what you deliberately left out.
- Run the case summary. Do not ask for a value, a grade, or a win probability.
- Open three citations yourself: one liability page, one medical page, one money page. Log the result in one line.
- Run the completeness review on the same upload. Order the two gaps it cites, if you agree the pages really name them.
- Stop. Do not draft the demand until those gaps are either in the file or written down as still missing.
That is the whole method. A partner can review the log in ten minutes. If you want a second matter, repeat the same six steps. Do not widen the test into a policy, a chronology guide, or a vendor scorecard. Mixing those jobs is how a first pass becomes a pile of drafts nobody checked.
Upload one case file and check the citations yourself
Frequently asked questions
What is AI litigation case analysis?
It is a cited first read of one litigation file. For a plaintiff personal injury firm, that means the posture, the parties, the proof, and the gaps, each tied to a page in the upload. It is not a verdict prediction, a case score, or a settlement number.
Can a case manager run the first pass?
Yes. The case manager or paralegal is usually the right person to choose the file and upload it. A lawyer still has to open the citations and decide what the draft may support. Nothing goes to a client, an adjuster, or a court until that review happens.
Does the analysis replace a medical chronology?
No. The first pass tells you what the file says and what is missing. The chronology is a later work product, built from the records and updated when missing reports arrive. Use the chronology guide for that method, and do not treat the summary as the chronology.
What should the firm check before uploading client records?
Read the product's security page and confirm, in its words, that uploads are not used to train shared models and that data is encrypted in transit and at rest. Formal Opinion 512 requires the lawyer to protect information relating to the representation. If the page will not say where the file goes, do not upload it.
How is this different from asking a chat tool about the case?
A chat tool answers from what you paste. It has not read the MRI, the bill, or the crash report unless you pasted them, and a paste is a poor way to handle a client file. A file analysis cites the firm's own pages, which a lawyer can open. If there is no page to open, it is not an analysis of the case.