← Insights

How to Ask a Jury for Pain and Suffering Damages: What the Research Says

What jury research says about anchors, lump sums versus per diem arguments, precise numbers and when to raise money, which states limit what you can ask for, and how to make a number credible to jurors who start out skeptical.

· TrialBase

Jurors find liability hard. They find damages harder. Asked to put a dollar figure on pain, lost sleep and a life narrowed by injury, most have no yardstick, no formula and no experience. In focus groups and post-trial interviews, the same questions come up again and again: How do we know what's fair? What are other juries doing in cases like this? Will the money do any good?

Jurors want help answering those questions. How you give that help, meaning whether you name a number, how you frame it and when you first raise money, affects the verdict more than many lawyers assume. Below is what the research shows, what the law allows, and how experienced trial lawyers put it together.

Jurors anchor, but they are not easy marks

Anchoring is the tendency to estimate an unknown value by starting from a number at hand and adjusting from it, usually not far enough. In the classic experiment, Tversky and Kahneman spun a rigged wheel of fortune that landed on 10 or 65, then asked people to estimate the percentage of African countries in the United Nations. People who saw 65 gave a median estimate of 45 percent. People who saw 10 gave 25 percent. The wheel number had nothing to do with the question, and it still moved the answers (Tversky & Kahneman, "Judgment Under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases," Science (1974)).

Mock-jury research shows the same pull on damages. McAuliff and Bornstein gave mock jurors a case about an 18-year-old pedestrian with spinal compression fractures. With no figure suggested, the average pain-and-suffering award was about $61,000. When counsel asked for $175,000, framed as a lump sum or as a small hourly figure over two years, average awards rose to roughly $150,000. Framed per month, the same total produced much less ("All Anchors Are Not Created Equal: The Effects of Per Diem Versus Lump Sum Requests on Pain and Suffering Awards," 34 Law & Human Behavior 164 (2010)).

Real juries are tougher than mock ones. The Arizona Jury Project recorded actual civil jury deliberations. In the analysis by Diamond and colleagues, jurors treated the lawyers' damages requests as arguments, not facts. They discounted them heavily, especially for pain and suffering, and often criticized amounts they saw as inflated. They also gave defense figures more credit than plaintiffs' figures ("Damage Anchors on Real Juries," 8 Journal of Empirical Legal Studies 148 (2011)). The same jurors also said they wanted guidance, because without it they had nothing to work from.

The lesson from both bodies of research: a number helps, but only one that jurors find credible. An anchor that strikes them as outrageous gets rejected, and it can cost the lawyer who named it.

Lump sum or per diem?

In the McAuliff and Bornstein study, a well-structured lump sum did as well as the best per diem framing, with less spread in the awards. Per diem framings were less predictable: hourly did well, monthly did poorly, and daily fell in between. If your jurisdiction allows both, a lump sum built on the evidence is often the safer choice. A per diem argument can still help a jury feel the duration of a lifelong injury, especially when you present it as an illustration rather than a formula.

Check your forum before choosing. The rules range widely:

  • California allows counsel to suggest a specific amount and to illustrate it on a per diem basis, with the instruction that counsel's arguments are not evidence (Beagle v. Vasold (1966) 65 Cal.2d 166; CACI No. 3905A).
  • New York and Illinois courts have rejected per diem formulas for pain and suffering while allowing lump-sum suggestions (e.g., Caley v. Manicke, 24 Ill.2d 390 (1962)).
  • New Jersey bars counsel from suggesting a dollar figure for pain and suffering (Botta v. Brunner, 26 N.J. 82 (1958)). Its court rule allows a time-unit argument only without reference to a specific sum (N.J. Ct. R. 1:7-1(b)).
  • Pennsylvania prohibits counsel from suggesting a specific amount for noneconomic damages.

These rules change, and judges in permissive states still police how numbers are argued. Confirm the current law and any standing order before you build the closing around a number.

Be precise, and build the number from the evidence

Precise numbers read as considered numbers. Marketing research on "price precision" finds that people judge a precise figure, such as $51,132, as smaller and more carefully calculated than a round one like $51,000 (Thomas, Simon & Kadiyali, "The Price Precision Effect," 29 Marketing Science 175 (2010)). That finding comes from pricing, not from juries, but it is consistent with what jurors say they want: a number that looks like it came from somewhere.

The best way to make a number come from somewhere is to build it in front of the jury from the evidence: the client's age and life expectancy, the surgeries, the months of therapy, the specific things the client can no longer do, and the testimony of the people who see them every day. Jurors in the Arizona project gave economic damages, such as medical bills and lost wages, much more weight than pain-and-suffering requests, because economic damages come with a yardstick. Give the noneconomic request as much structure as the economic one.

Keep anchors inside the record. Some trial lawyers use large figures from the evidence to anchor the jury: the value of the contract at stake, or the employer's monthly profit. Be careful. In most states the defendant's wealth is off limits for compensatory damages and comes in only on punitive damages, often in a separate phase. A number that has nothing to do with the injury, raised to inflate the award, invites an objection, a curative instruction, or a reversal on appeal. Use only figures that are relevant and admitted.

When to raise money: voir dire, opening or closing

Research on "money priming" suggests that thinking about money makes people more self-focused and less inclined to help others (Vohs, Mead & Goode, "Merely Activating the Concept of Money Changes Personal and Interpersonal Behavior," 17 Current Directions in Psychological Science 208 (2008)). That cuts against raising money early and often. Jury selection, on the other hand, is the only chance to find the jurors who could never award a significant sum, whatever the evidence.

Experienced lawyers resolve this differently, and there is no single right answer. One common approach is to talk in voir dire about the importance of the case and ask whether anyone has a figure in mind so large, or so small, that they could not award it no matter what the law and the evidence showed. Some lawyers test both ends with a very small and a very large hypothetical and use the answers for cause challenges. Whether you may mention specific amounts in jury selection depends on your court, so ask before you do it. Then save the actual request for closing, after the evidence has given the jury the reasons for it.

Credibility is the anchor that holds

The jurors in the Arizona project were critical consumers of the lawyers' numbers. What makes a request credible:

  • A number that fits the evidence. Jurors heavily discount requests that look untethered from the proof.
  • A lawyer who is sincere. Admit the weaknesses in the case before the defense does. Jurors reward candor and punish overreaching, and that applies to the lawyer as much as to the client.
  • A client who is candid. A plaintiff who admits improvement, and doesn't exaggerate, makes every number more believable. That work starts long before trial, with deposition and exam preparation.
  • A response to the defense number. Jurors in the Arizona project took defense figures seriously. If the defense offers an alternative figure, explain to the jury why it is wrong. Don't let it stand as the only reasonable number in the room.
  • An answer to "will the money do any good?" Connect the award to what it will actually pay for, and to what the law asks jurors to do: compensate fully for harms that money cannot undo.

Before trial: anchoring in negotiation

The same psychology applies before trial. A well-supported first demand anchors the negotiation. Waiting for the defense to make the first offer hands them the anchor. The rule is the same as at trial: the demand works only if the adjuster and defense counsel can see where the number came from. A demand built line by line on the records anchors. An unsupported round number gets discounted, just as it does in the jury room.

Frequently asked questions

Should I ask the jury for a specific amount of pain and suffering damages? Research suggests that a credible, evidence-based figure produces higher and more consistent awards than no figure at all. Whether you may suggest one, and in what form, depends on your state.

Is a per diem argument better than a lump sum? Not reliably. In the leading mock-jury study, a lump sum did as well as the best per diem framing, with more consistent results. Some states also prohibit per diem arguments.

Can I mention the defendant's wealth when arguing damages? Generally not for compensatory damages. A defendant's financial condition is usually admissible only on punitive damages, and often only in a separate phase of the trial.

When should I first mention money to the jury? Lawyers differ. Many use jury selection to identify jurors who could not award a significant sum, and save the specific request for closing.

What is anchoring in a jury trial? The tendency of jurors to estimate an unknown amount, such as pain and suffering, by starting from a number they have heard and adjusting from it. A credible number from counsel tends to pull awards toward it. An implausible one tends to be rejected.

How do jurors decide pain and suffering damages? In most states the instruction gives them no formula. California's, for example, tells jurors that no fixed standard exists and that they must use their judgment to decide a reasonable amount based on the evidence and their common sense (CACI No. 3905A). That is why jurors look for guidance from the evidence and from counsel.

How much of the requested amount do juries actually award? Usually much less than plaintiffs ask, especially for pain and suffering. Juries in the Arizona Jury Project discounted plaintiffs' noneconomic requests heavily, and gave economic damages backed by bills and wage records much more weight.

Are there caps on pain and suffering damages? In some states and some kinds of cases, most often medical malpractice. California's medical malpractice cap on noneconomic damages, for example, was restructured in 2023 and rises each year. Check your state's caps before you build a number. Juries are often not told about the cap.

Does the "precise number" effect apply to juries? The research on precise numbers comes from pricing and negotiation, not from jury studies. It fits what jurors say they want, a number that looks calculated, but treat it as a sensible practice rather than a proven jury effect.

Should the plaintiff testify about the money? No. Jurors should hear about the harms from the plaintiff, the family and the doctors. The number belongs in counsel's argument, built from that testimony.

Can the same anchoring principles be used in a settlement demand? Yes. A well-supported opening demand anchors the negotiation, and an unsupported round number gets discounted, just as in the jury room.

How TrialBase helps

A credible number starts with a complete record. TrialBase reads the whole case file and builds the medical chronology and special damages with every figure cited to its page. It then drafts a trial plan that connects each element of damages to the witnesses and exhibits that prove it, so the number you ask for is one the jury can trace back to the evidence.

← All insights