Medical Records Retrieval for Personal Injury Lawyers: A Practical Guide
What to request from each provider, the three ways to get records (authorization, the patient access right and subpoena), what HIPAA actually requires of a plaintiff firm, what records cost, and how to know the file is complete before the demand or the expert report.
· TrialBase
Medical records prove the three things every personal injury case needs: that the client was hurt, that the incident caused it, and what it has cost. The defense reads the same records looking for the opposite: the prior complaint, the gap in treatment, the note that says "doing well." A case is only as strong as the records behind it, and most problems with records start at retrieval. A provider was never asked. The chart came back without the imaging or the nursing notes. The bill doesn't match the visits. The records arrived after the expert's report was due.
This guide covers what to request, how to get it, what HIPAA does and doesn't require of a plaintiff's firm, and how to know the file is complete.
Start with the provider list, and keep it growing
Build the list at intake: every ambulance, emergency room, urgent care, primary care doctor, specialist, therapist, chiropractor, imaging center, pharmacy and hospital since the incident. Add the client's regular providers for the years before it, because the defense will request them.
Then let the records extend the list. Discharge notes name the follow-up doctor. Referrals name the specialist. Imaging reports name the ordering physician. Pharmacy records show who prescribed what. Every provider a record mentions but whose chart you don't have is a request you still need to send, and a question the defense will ask if you don't.
What to request from each provider
"All medical records" means different things to different records departments. Ask for the complete chart, by category:
- The full chart for the date range: office and progress notes, histories, consults and correspondence.
- Emergency and hospital records, including triage, nursing notes, medication administration records and discharge instructions, not just the physician's summary.
- The EMS or ambulance run report. It often records the first description of the mechanism of injury and the earliest complaints.
- Imaging: the radiologist's reports and the images themselves (usually DICOM files on a disc or download). Experts often want to see the films, not just read the report.
- Operative and procedure reports, anesthesia records and pathology.
- Therapy records: initial evaluations, daily notes and discharge summaries.
- Pharmacy records.
- Itemized billing: the ledger or itemized statement with CPT codes and dates of service, and the latest dated statement.
- Payment and adjustment records: what was paid, by whom, and what was written off. In California, a plaintiff recovers past medical expenses only up to the amount actually paid or incurred, not the full amount billed (Howell v. Hamilton Meats & Provisions, Inc. (2011) 52 Cal.4th 541). Without the payment records, you can't state the specials correctly.
- Prior records for the relevant body parts, for an appropriate period before the incident. Get them before the defense does, so you know what is in them.
- The audit trail, in the rare case where the integrity or timing of an electronic chart is in dispute.
Three ways to get the records
1. A HIPAA authorization signed by the client
The usual route before suit. The client signs a HIPAA-compliant authorization (45 C.F.R. § 164.508) naming the provider, the firm, the records and the time period. Many providers require their own form or an online portal. Use it, because a request on the wrong form often goes to the bottom of the pile.
In California, an attorney with the patient's written authorization may inspect and copy the records before suit, and the provider must make them available within five days or send copies within ten (Cal. Evid. Code § 1158). A provider who fails to comply without good cause can be liable for the reasonable expenses of enforcing the request.
2. The patient's right of access, directed to the firm
Under HIPAA, patients have a right to their own records, and a provider must act on a request within 30 days, with one 30-day extension if it explains the delay in writing (45 C.F.R. § 164.524). A patient can direct the provider to send the records to a third party, such as their lawyer.
The cost depends on where the records go. HIPAA caps what a provider may charge a patient for their own copies at a reasonable, cost-based fee. After Ciox Health, LLC v. Azar, 435 F. Supp. 3d 30 (D.D.C. 2020), that cap no longer applies when the patient directs the records to a third party like a law firm. Those requests can be billed at the rates state law allows. When cost matters, having the client request copies for themselves and pass them to you can be considerably cheaper. The trade-off is time and the client's follow-through.
3. Subpoena, once suit is filed
After the case is filed, a records subpoena reaches providers who ignore requests, and it produces records with a custodian's certification. Two sets of rules apply:
- HIPAA. A provider may release records in response to a subpoena that isn't signed by a judge only if it receives satisfactory assurance that the patient was given notice and a chance to object, or that the parties have sought a qualified protective order limiting use of the records to the litigation (45 C.F.R. § 164.512(e)).
- State procedure. In California, a deposition subpoena for a patient's medical records requires a notice to the consumer, served at least 10 days before production if served personally (15 days if by mail), so the patient can object (Cal. Code Civ. Proc. § 1985.3). The custodian produces the records with a declaration that they are true and complete copies made in the ordinary course of business (Cal. Evid. Code §§ 1560–1561). That declaration makes them admissible without calling the custodian (Cal. Evid. Code § 1562).
The defense will subpoena records too, often far beyond what the case puts at issue. When you receive the consumer notice, read the subpoena for scope: the body parts and time period it reaches, and whether it seeks mental health or other sensitive records. Object to what goes too far.
Records that need more than a standard authorization
- Psychotherapy notes (a therapist's separate session notes) require their own specific authorization under HIPAA (45 C.F.R. § 164.508(a)(2)).
- Substance use disorder treatment records from federally assisted programs are governed by separate federal rules (42 C.F.R. Part 2) with their own consent requirements.
- State law adds protection for categories such as mental health, HIV testing and genetic information. Check the requirements before you request them, and before you decide whether you need them at all.
HIPAA and your firm
A plaintiff's firm that obtains its own client's records is generally not a HIPAA "business associate." A business associate works on behalf of a provider or health plan, and the plaintiff's firm works for the patient. You don't sign a business associate agreement with the hospital to get your client's chart.
That doesn't lower the duty to protect the records. Lawyers must make reasonable efforts to prevent unauthorized access to client information (ABA Model Rule of Professional Conduct 1.6(c)), and state privacy and data-security laws apply. Keep medical records in a system with access controls, share them with experts and vendors through secure channels, and produce them to the defense under a protective order where the case calls for one.
Track every request until it is complete
Retrieval fails quietly. A request sent in March and never followed up becomes a missing chart in October, when the expert needs it. Keep a log for each provider:
- The request: date sent, method, records requested, date range.
- Follow-up: a scheduled date for the next call, and the name of the person spoken to each time.
- Receipt: date received, page count, and whether a certification came with it.
- Completeness: whether everything requested arrived. If the provider has no records, get a written certificate of no records.
When the records arrive, check them against each other:
- Every bill should have a record, and every record should have a bill. Match the charges to the visits by date of service. A charge with no matching note, or a visit with no charge, is something to explain or fix before the demand goes out.
- Use the latest dated billing statement for the specials. Earlier statements are often superseded by later payments and adjustments.
- Look for references to missing records: a test that was ordered but never reported, a referral with no follow-up chart, an MRI the surgeon reviewed that you don't have.
- Check for other patients' pages, a common and serious error in large productions.
Records retrieval services can save staff time, especially across many providers in many states. Hold them to the same standard: complete charts, certifications, a status report on every request, and secure handling. A vendor's "complete" production still needs the same review.
Using the records in the case
Medical records are usually admitted under the business records exception: in federal court on a custodian's testimony or written certification (Fed. R. Evid. 803(6), 902(11)), and in California through the custodian's declaration (Cal. Evid. Code §§ 1271, 1560–1562). Being admissible does not make everything in a record usable. Statements by third parties recorded in a chart, and medical opinions, can raise separate objections. Causation usually needs an expert to explain it.
Organize the records so others can follow them: one file per provider, Bates numbers on every page, and a chronology that cites each entry to its page. That chronology is the foundation for the demand letter, the deposition outlines, the expert's review and the trial exhibits.
Frequently asked questions
How long does a provider have to send medical records? Under HIPAA's right of access, 30 days from the request, with one 30-day extension if the provider explains the delay in writing. In California, a provider responding to an attorney's request with the patient's authorization must make records available for inspection within five days or send copies within ten (Cal. Evid. Code § 1158).
How much can a provider charge a law firm for medical records? HIPAA's cost-based fee cap applies to copies a patient requests for themselves. Since Ciox Health v. Azar (2020), it does not apply to records the patient directs to a third party such as a law firm, so those requests are billed at the rates state law allows. Check your state's copy-fee statute.
Is a personal injury law firm a HIPAA business associate? Generally not, when it obtains its own client's records. A business associate acts on behalf of a provider or health plan, and a plaintiff's firm acts for the patient. The firm still has ethical and state-law duties to protect the records.
What is the difference between a HIPAA authorization and a records subpoena? An authorization is the patient's written permission for a provider to release records, and it is the usual route before suit. A subpoena compels production during litigation. Under HIPAA, it requires notice to the patient or a qualified protective order, and in California it requires a notice to the consumer.
What records should I request in a personal injury case? The complete chart for each provider: notes, emergency and nursing records, the EMS report, imaging reports and images, operative and therapy records, pharmacy records, itemized bills, payment and adjustment records, and relevant prior records.
What if a provider says it has no records? Ask for a written certificate of no records, and check the date range, the spelling of the patient's name and any other names or facilities the provider uses. A "no records" response is sometimes a search error.
What should I do when a provider ignores a records request? Follow up on a fixed schedule and document each contact. In California, a provider that fails to comply with Evidence Code section 1158 can be liable for the cost of enforcing the request. Patients can also complain to the HHS Office for Civil Rights about right-of-access violations. After suit, a records subpoena compels production.
Can the defense get my client's entire medical history? Not automatically. Discovery is generally limited to records relevant to the conditions the case puts at issue, for a reasonable time period. Object to blanket authorizations and to subpoenas that reach unrelated conditions or sensitive categories such as mental health.
Do I need the actual imaging, or just the radiology report? Request both. The report is enough for the chronology, but treating doctors, experts and sometimes the jury need to see the images themselves.
How do I know the medical file is complete? Every provider mentioned in any record has produced a chart or a certificate of no records, every bill matches a record by date of service, every ordered test has a result, and the billing reflects the latest dated statement.
How TrialBase helps
Knowing what is missing is the hard part. TrialBase reads the whole case file and lists what it lacks: the provider named in a discharge note whose chart was never requested, the bill with no matching record, the test ordered but never reported. Each finding is cited to the page that raised it, with the records request drafted. Once the records are in, TrialBase builds the medical chronology and special damages from them, with every entry cited to its page.