← Insights

What Not to Say in a Deposition: 12 Questions Designed to Box You In

The words that hurt witnesses under oath, and twelve questions lawyers use to lock in testimony, each with a weak answer and a better one, all of them true.

· TrialBase

Witnesses rarely lose a case by lying at a deposition. They lose ground with words they didn't need to say: a guess offered to be helpful, an apology, a casual "always," a stranger's motives explained, or a friendly summary agreed to without listening to it. The court reporter takes down every one of those words, and the other side can read them to a jury a year later.

This guide covers the words to leave out and then the twelve questions experienced lawyers use to box a witness in, each with a weak answer and a better one. Every "better answer" below assumes it is true. The point is never to shade the truth. It is to say the truth precisely and stop. If you have a lawyer, go over this with them. If you are representing yourself, read our guide to preparing for your own deposition first.

Words and phrases to leave out

"I guess…" and "Probably…" If you are guessing, the honest answer is "I don't know." A guess written down in a transcript reads like a fact. Estimates are fine when you have a real basis for them ("about twenty minutes, I drive it every day"). Guesses are not.

"To be honest…," "Honestly…," "I'm telling the truth." These suggest that your other answers might not be honest. Leave them out of every answer.

"Always," "never," "exactly," "every time." Absolutes are easy to disprove with one counterexample. "I never use my phone while driving" invites the lawyer to pull your phone records. If the truth is "not that I recall" or "I don't make a habit of it," say that.

"I'm sure I…" when you mean "I assume I did." "I'm sure I stopped at the sign" sounds like a memory, but it often means "I usually stop there." Say what you actually remember, and say plainly when you are reasoning from habit.

"I must have…," "I would have…," "So I probably…" This is thinking out loud. Work it out silently, then give the answer: what you remember, or "I don't remember."

"I'm sorry, I should know that." Never apologize for not knowing or not remembering. It makes the rest of your testimony look shaky.

"I don't remember. It was years ago, who would?" Don't explain why you don't remember. The lawyer will spend the next ten minutes listing things you do remember from that year. "I don't remember" is the complete answer.

"I wasn't really paying attention." That is an admission that can be used against you, and it was not what the question asked. Answer the question: what you saw, or that you don't remember.

"My lawyer told me…" Conversations with your lawyer are privileged. Starting an answer this way can put that privilege at risk. Describe what you know and how you know it, but not what your lawyer said.

"I tore my rotator cuff." Unless you are a doctor, describe your symptoms and give diagnoses as what you were told: "My shoulder hurt when I lifted my arm. The doctor told me it was a torn rotator cuff."

"Off the record…" Nothing is off the record unless every lawyer agrees and the reporter stops typing. Assume every word in the room, and in the hallway near the reporter, is on the record.

"Yeah," "like," "you know," jokes and sarcasm. A transcript has no tone of voice. A joke reads as a statement, and sarcasm reads as a sincere admission. Say "yes."

Small talk is testimony too. "How are you feeling today?" before the questioning starts is still a question asked under oath. Be polite, and be accurate.

12 questions designed to box you in

1. "Is it fair to say…?"

Q: Is it fair to say you were in a hurry that morning? Weak: Yeah, I guess so. Better: No. I left at my usual time.

The words that follow "is it fair to say" are usually not fair. You don't have to accept the lawyer's characterization. Answer in your own words, or say "Yes, but…" and finish the sentence.

2. The true statement with a premise tucked inside

Q: So you went to Dr. Okafor because Dr. Patel wasn't helping you? Weak: Yes. Better: I wanted a second opinion.

Part of the question is true: you went to a new doctor. Part is a criticism of your treating doctor that you never made. "Yes" adopts the whole sentence. Answer only the part that is true.

3. "So what you're telling me is…"

Q: So what you're telling me is the light could have been yellow. Weak: I suppose it could have. Better: No. I said I saw the light turn red before I entered the intersection.

A restatement is a new question, and it rarely restates you accurately. If it doesn't match what you said, say so and repeat your answer.

4. "Before the accident, had you ever had back pain?"

Weak: No. Better: Occasional soreness after yard work, like most people. Nothing I saw a doctor for.

Almost everyone has had some back pain. A flat "no" that the other side later disproves with one old urgent-care visit damages your credibility on everything. Answer the question actually asked, accurately, and don't assume the lawyer means only serious pain.

5. The oversimplification

Q: So after the injection wore off, you were right back where you started? Weak: Pretty much. Better: No. It helped for about a week. After that the pain came back, but not as bad as before the injection.

Lawyers cast things in black and white because nuance helps the other side. If the truth has shades, give them.

6. "How fast were you going? How many seconds?"

Weak: About 25 miles an hour, and he was maybe 50 feet away for 5 seconds. Better: I was driving at about the speed limit. He pulled out suddenly. I don't know how many feet or seconds.

Most people estimate speed, distance and time badly, and a confident wrong number can sink a case. Give a number only if you actually have a basis for it, such as a glance at the speedometer. Otherwise, descriptive words like "suddenly" or "quickly" are more accurate.

7. "Give me your best estimate."

Q: I understand you don't know exactly. Just give me your best estimate. Weak: Fine, three seconds? Better: I can't estimate it. Anything I said would be a guess.

The push for an estimate often comes three or four times. If you have no basis for one, your answer does not change because the question is repeated.

8. "Tell me every way this injury has affected you."

Weak: I can't lift my grandkids and I don't sleep well. Better: The ones I can think of right now are… [the full, honest list]. There are probably others that will come to me later.

This question is meant to lock in your list, so anything you leave out today can be challenged at trial. It is also the one place in a deposition to say more, not less. Give the full, truthful picture, and keep the list open.

9. "Why did the other driver do that?"

Weak: He was probably texting. Better: I don't know why he did it.

What another person thought, intended or knew is a guess unless they told you. Testify to what you saw and heard. If you saw the phone in his hand, say that, and only that.

10. "Does this document refresh your recollection?"

Weak: Yes, if that's what it says, that's what happened. Better: I've read it. It doesn't bring back my own memory of that conversation.

Say yes only if reading the document actually brings back your own memory. Agreeing that a record is accurate is not the same as remembering. Ask to see any document you are asked about, and read all of it, not just the line the lawyer points to.

11. "Did you think about calling the police?"

Weak: I guess I should have. Better: I don't remember whether I thought about it.

"Did you think…" and "Did you consider…" questions ask whether you remember having a particular thought at a particular moment. Often you don't. And "I should have" answers a question nobody asked.

12. "What did you do to prepare for today? What did your lawyer tell you?"

Weak: My lawyer told me not to mention the earlier accident. Better: I met with my attorney and reviewed my interrogatory answers.

You will probably be asked what you reviewed and whom you met with. Answer truthfully. What you and your lawyer said to each other is privileged. If you have a lawyer, they will object and may instruct you not to answer that part. If you are representing yourself, you can decline to repeat conversations with a lawyer you consulted. Any document you used to refresh your memory may have to be shown to the other side (Fed. R. Evid. 612; Cal. Evid. Code § 771).

The silence after your answer

The last trap is no question at all. You finish your answer and the lawyer just looks at you. Most people fill a silence. Don't. You have answered. If the lawyer asks "Anything else?" the honest answer is often "That's all I can think of right now."

What to do instead: listen, think, take your time

Every rule above comes down to three words. Listen to the whole question. Think about whether you heard it, understood it, and actually know the answer. Take your time, then give the shortest true answer and stop. "Yes," "no," "I don't know," "I don't remember" and "I don't understand the question" are complete answers when they are true.

Frequently asked questions

Is it bad to say "I don't remember" a lot? Not if it's true. "I don't remember" is a better answer than a guess. It becomes a problem only when it isn't true, or when you remember convenient details and forget inconvenient ones.

What if I realize I said something wrong? Correct it as soon as you notice: "I'd like to correct an earlier answer." You can also correct errors when you review the transcript, usually within 30 days of being told it is ready (Cal. Code Civ. Proc. § 2025.520; Fed. R. Civ. P. 30(e), if review was requested before the deposition ended). The original answer stays in the record, so it is better to get it right the first time.

Can I refuse to answer a question? Usually not. You can generally refuse only to protect a privilege, where a court order limits the questioning, or to stop the deposition so you can ask the court for a protective order if the questioning is in bad faith or meant to harass (Fed. R. Civ. P. 30(c)(2), 30(d)(3); Cal. Code Civ. Proc. §§ 2025.420, 2025.470). Otherwise, answer, even over an objection.

Can I ask the lawyer to repeat or rephrase the question? Yes, as many times as you honestly need. It is the lawyer's job to ask a clear question.

Related guides

← All insights