How to Prepare Your Client for a Deposition Like a Pro
The briefing experienced trial lawyers give before a client testifies: what to explain and in what order, the questions that box witnesses in, the cues to agree on before the deposition starts, and why the same briefing gets a client through cross-examination at trial.
· TrialBase
For most clients, the deposition is the only sworn testimony they will ever give. Defense counsel uses it for two things. The first is the record: every answer can be read to a jury a year later, and a careless one can end the case on summary judgment. The second is the report to the carrier, which rates how credible and how likable your client will be in front of a jury. That rating moves the reserve, and the reserve moves the offer.
Clients rarely hurt their case by lying. They hurt it by talking: explaining, guessing, apologizing, filling silences, and agreeing with a friendly lawyer's summary of their life. A good briefing fixes that. Below is the briefing trial lawyers have refined over decades of defending plaintiff and lay-witness depositions, in the order that works. It assumes a plaintiff in an injury case, but most of it applies to any client or friendly witness.
Start with what the client already knows
Open with one plain question: "Have you ever been deposed?" The answer tells you whether this client follows legal vocabulary or works it out from context. If they are unsure what "deposed" means, ask again without saying you are rephrasing: "Have you ever testified under oath?"
Then explain how a deposition works before you get to any facts of the case. Clients retain the facts better once they understand the setting.
- The oath is the same oath they would take in court. The court reporter swears them in, and the testimony carries the same duty to tell the truth, and the same penalty for perjury, as testimony in front of a judge and jury.
- Everything is taken down. The reporter can record only spoken words, not nods, shrugs or "uh-huh." If the deposition is on video, the jury may see the client's face as well as hear the answers.
- One lawyer asks questions at a time. Several lawyers may be in the room, but it is a question-and-answer session, not a panel interrogation.
- The client does not have to win the case today. Other witnesses will testify, and experts will give the opinions. The client's job is to give facts: what they saw, heard, did and felt. Nobody remembers every detail of their own life, and a witness who seems to would not be believed anyway.
- The other lawyer is not their friend. This is the point clients understand least. However courteous and charming defense counsel is, their job is to see that your client recovers as little as possible. Most clients nod at this and then forget it within ten minutes of being treated warmly. Say it more than once.
The job is to answer the question asked, truthfully, and then stop
Tell the client plainly that the deposition is not our show. Trial is where we tell their story. At the deposition, the other side asks and the client answers only what is asked. An important fact that nobody asks about does not come up today.
That is different from how honest people talk in everyday life, so explain the difference. With family, a good friend or a member of the clergy, being honest means telling the whole story. Under oath, it means answering the specific question asked, truthfully. If the client wants to help defense counsel understand, ask them why they would help someone whose job is to reduce what they recover.
The examples clients remember are short:
Q: Are you married? A: Yes.
Not: "Yes, twenty-two years, and she has had to do everything for me since the crash."
Volunteering also costs time. Every unasked fact opens a new line of questions, often ten or twenty of them. The more the client says, the longer the deposition runs. A witness who listens, thinks and gives short answers finishes sooner, even with a pause before every answer.
Here is what volunteering looks like on a transcript (a fictional example):
Q: What did Dr. Patel discuss with you at your first visit after the surgery? A: I don't remember, but I know she sent me to physical therapy at Riverside a week later. Q: I'm not asking about therapy yet. What, if anything, did Dr. Patel discuss with you at that visit? A: I don't remember.
The second answer should have been the first one. The extra half sentence gained nothing and gave the examiner a new topic to explore on his own terms.
Two more points belong here. First, once the answer is complete, the client says nothing until the next question. Silence after an answer is not the client's problem to fill. Experienced examiners pause and wait, sometimes with a raised eyebrow, because people rush to fill silences. Second, compare the deposition to a job interview, not to a conversation. In an interview you are polite, honest and yourself, but you do not offer information that hurts your chances, make jokes, or get too relaxed.
Four answers are almost always enough
When they are true, "yes," "no," "I don't know" and "I don't remember" are the best answers a witness can give. Explain the difference between the last two, because it matters at trial:
- "I don't know" means the client never had the information. Asked the defendant driver's home address, the honest answer is almost always "I don't know."
- "I don't remember" means the client once knew and no longer recalls. Asked the color of the other driver's jacket at the scene, a client who saw him but cannot picture it now should say "I don't remember."
A fifth answer is just as important: "I don't understand the question." It is the examiner's job to ask a clear question, not the client's job to work out what he meant. If the client understands every word but cannot see how to give a short, direct answer, they probably did not really understand the question. "Could you repeat that?" or "Could you rephrase that?" is a complete answer, and the client can give it as often as they honestly need to.
Some honest answers are not one of the four. That is fine, but the answer should still be the shortest true one. Asked whether the light was red, the answer is "Yes," not "Yes, I could see it clearly because the sun was behind me."
Never explain and never apologize. "I don't remember, that was years ago, who would?" invites the examiner to list everything else the client remembers from that year. "I wasn't paying attention" is an admission, given away for free. "I'm sorry, I should know that" makes the client look unreliable on everything else. When the honest answer is "I don't remember," those three words are the whole answer.
Estimates are fine. Guesses are not.
The law expects a witness to give a good-faith estimate when they have a basis for one. It never requires a guess. Give the client an example from their own life. They can estimate how many miles are on their own car without checking, because they drive it every day. They cannot estimate the miles on yours, so any number they give would be a guess.
Spend time on time, speed and distance. Most people estimate them poorly, and a confident wrong number ("I was stopped for at least ten seconds") can do serious damage. If timing is an issue, have the client watch a second hand for five seconds to feel how long that is. Unless they actually know a number, descriptive words such as "suddenly" or "quickly" are usually more accurate than seconds or feet. When pressed for a "best estimate" they cannot honestly give, they keep saying so, as many times as they are asked.
Teach the client to hear the trap inside the question
Most of a defense deposition is leading questions. Clients do not need to know the rules of evidence, but they do need to recognize these patterns:
- "Is it fair to say…" and "Wouldn't you agree…" usually come just before something unfair. The client does not have to accept the examiner's wording. They can answer in their own words, or say "Yes, but…" and finish the sentence.
- The embedded premise is the subtle version. "So you switched to Dr. Okafor because Dr. Patel wasn't helping you?" Most of that is true: the client wanted a second opinion. Tucked inside is a criticism of the treating doctor. Answering "yes" adopts the criticism. The right answer is the true part only: "I wanted a second opinion."
- The oversimplification. If the client said a treatment helped for about a week, the next question may be "So after a week you were right back where you started?" Real life has more shades than that, and the client does not have to follow the lead.
- "Before the accident, had you ever had back pain?" Nearly everyone has. The client should not answer "no" on the assumption that the examiner means serious or lasting pain, unless the question says so.
- "Did you think…?" and "Did you consider…?" The real question is whether the client remembers actually having that thought. "I don't remember whether I thought that" is often the honest answer.
- Frame-by-frame questions. Examiners ask about an accident as if memory were film that can be advanced frame by frame. Nobody remembers a sudden event that way. The client describes what they actually recall and stops there.
- Other people's minds. What someone else meant, intended or knew is a guess unless that person told the client. Almost all of the client's testimony should be about their own perceptions and state of mind.
- Statements that are not questions. A remark meant to provoke a response does not need one. The client waits for a question.
- Documents. If asked about a record, the client asks to see it and reads all of it, not just the highlighted line. If asked whether a document "refreshes your recollection," the answer is yes only if it actually brings back their own memory.
- Medical words. The client describes symptoms ("my shoulder hurt when I lifted my arm") and gives diagnoses only as what they were told ("the doctor told me it was a torn rotator cuff").
- Pain on a scale of one to ten. A number for past pain is hard to give accurately and easy to use against the client later. The honest answer may be a description rather than a number.
Practice these patterns in a short mock examination. The point is not to script answers. It is to let the client hear a slanted question in your voice before they hear it from the other side. For a client handout with twelve of these questions and weak and better answers side by side, see What Not to Say in a Deposition.
Damages are the exception: loosen the reins
The short-answer rule bends when the questions turn to general damages: how the injury changed the client's work, sleep, family life and the things they used to enjoy. Here the client should say as much as they honestly can. A bare "it's been hard" undersells the case and will be quoted back at trial.
Defense counsel will also try to box the claim in with a broad question, such as "Tell me every way this injury has affected you," and then hold the client to that list at trial. Teach the client to keep the list open with a truthful qualifier: "The ones I can think of right now are…" or "…those are the ones that come to mind today." For permanent impairments, it is accurate to say they cannot list everything but can give examples.
Two warnings go with this. The client should not exaggerate or minimize. Exaggeration is impeachment waiting to happen, and so is a minimized answer that later grows. And the client should be candid about improvement. If some injuries have healed, the client says so. Juries punish plaintiffs who overreach, and the plaintiffs who do best are usually candid and even a little self-effacing.
Finally, tell the client which answers have legal consequences they cannot see. The classic example is the statute of limitations under the discovery rule. A plaintiff in a toxic-exposure case who is asked when she first suspected the exposure caused her illness, and who answers "oh, ten years ago" without thinking, may have just lost her case on summary judgment. Identify the questions in your case that carry that kind of weight, and make sure the client understands them without telling them what to say.
Agree on the cues before the deposition starts
Defending counsel may not coach during the deposition. Rules and judges increasingly police speaking objections. Under the federal rules, objections must be stated "concisely in a nonargumentative and nonsuggestive manner" (Fed. R. Civ. P. 30(c)(2)). So the teaching has to happen in the briefing. Agree on these points in advance:
- When I start talking, you stop, even in the middle of a word.
- Objections are usually for the record. Most objections are to the form of the question and must be made at the deposition or they are waived (Cal. Code Civ. Proc. § 2025.460(b); Fed. R. Civ. P. 32(d)(3)(B)). After the objection, the client answers unless told not to. Teach the client to treat any objection as a reason to listen to the question again. If, on reflection, they did not understand it, they say so. If they did, they answer it.
- An instruction not to answer is rare, and the client follows it. In California, an instruction not to answer is generally proper only to protect a privilege, work product or a privacy right, or to suspend the deposition and seek a protective order. An instruction based on relevance or form is discovery abuse and draws sanctions (Stewart v. Colonial Western Agency, Inc. (2001) 87 Cal.App.4th 1006; Cal. Code Civ. Proc. §§ 2025.460, 2025.470). In federal court it is limited to preserving a privilege, enforcing a court-ordered limit, or presenting a motion under Rule 30(d)(3) (Fed. R. Civ. P. 30(c)(2)). The examiner will often ask next, "Are you going to follow your lawyer's instruction?" The answer is "Yes," and nothing more.
- Breaks are available, but not while a question is pending. The client can ask for a break whenever they need one: tired, emotional, angry or just losing focus. A deposition is not an endurance test. They ask after answering, not in the middle of a question. Courts agree that counsel should not confer with the witness while a question is pending, except to decide whether to assert a privilege. Some judges, following Hall v. Clifton Precision, 150 F.R.D. 525 (E.D. Pa. 1993), also restrict conferences during breaks, so check your forum's rules and any standing order. Asking to step out with counsel is the client's right, but doing it often costs credibility.
- Nothing is off the record. Saying "off the record" does not stop the reporter unless all counsel agree. Comments about the case wait until you are alone. The reporter is a neutral officer, not the client's confidant, so no small talk about the case near the reporter either.
- The client never argues. The examiner may try to provoke anger. Being angry on the client's behalf is the lawyer's job.
The record: what to review, what to bring, how to sound
- Review prior sworn discovery responses. Interrogatory answers, responses to requests for admission and any verified pleading are sworn testimony. Contradicting them hands the other side impeachment.
- Be careful about what the client reviews to refresh memory. Documents a witness uses to refresh recollection, before or during the deposition, can become discoverable (Fed. R. Evid. 612; Cal. Evid. Code § 771, which California courts apply at depositions). Choose them with that in mind, and keep privileged material, such as your notes and memos to the client, out of the stack. Your conversations with the client stay privileged. The client will probably be asked what they reviewed to prepare. They answer truthfully, and they never begin an answer with "my lawyer told me."
- Bring nothing unless the notice demands it, and never offer to look for or produce documents. If asked to draw a diagram, the client should decline unless you say otherwise. If you allow it, the client says on the record that it is a rough sketch, not to scale.
- Sound like testimony. People get their proper names, and doctors get their titles. The client says "yes," not "yeah." No jokes, no slang. Never say "to be honest" or "I'm telling the truth," because both imply the other answers might not be. Where the client is sure, no "I think." Where they are not sure, they say so.
- Don't think out loud. "Well, I was getting ready for dinner, so I must have been…" is speculation, recorded word for word. The client thinks silently, then answers. If they stop partway and are pressed to finish, "I have finished my answer" is a complete reply.
- Dress for an office. For a remote deposition: a quiet room, the camera at eye level, no notes in view, no one else in the room, and the phone face down. See our remote deposition setup checklist.
- When it ends, leave. Lingering invites "just one more question."
- Read and sign. The client usually has 30 days after notice that the transcript is ready to review it and make corrections (Cal. Code Civ. Proc. § 2025.520; Fed. R. Civ. P. 30(e), when review is requested before the deposition ends). The original answer stays in the record and can be read at trial next to the change, so the goal is an accurate transcript the first time. More in our guide to the deposition transcript correction process.
The whole briefing in three words: listen, think, take your time
After 30 to 60 minutes of instructions, give the client the summary that makes it stick. Experienced trial lawyers boil the whole briefing down to three words: listen, think and take your time. A client who listens to the whole question, thinks about whether they heard it, understood it and know the answer, and only then answers, will follow every other rule without trying to remember it. The rules go out the window when the client rushes.
A simple drill helps first-time witnesses. From the first question, the client repeats each question silently, forms the answer silently, and only then speaks. "She asked my name. My name is Jane Doe." Then: "Jane Doe." It feels silly on easy questions, which is the point. It is far easier to start slow and speed up than to start fast, blurt, and try to slow down.
Say the three words at the end of the briefing, and say them again in the hallway before the deposition starts. A client who is truthful and takes a moment before every answer does not need to worry about staying consistent. The truth stays consistent on its own.
The same briefing prepares a client for cross-examination at trial
Cross-examination at trial runs on the same principles, with three differences to cover in the trial-prep session:
- The jury is watching. Demeanor matters more than at the deposition. Warmth, patience and candor are persuasive, and visible irritation with opposing counsel is not.
- The deposition transcript is the impeachment tool. Opposing counsel will read any inconsistency back to the jury, line by line. Have the client reread their deposition before trial, and fix real errors through the proper channels before trial, not on the stand.
- There is no stepping out to talk to counsel. The client stays on the stand until cross is over. Redirect is where you repair, so tell the client that a short, honest answer on cross is not the end of the story.
A one-page checklist for the client
- Tell the truth. Always.
- Listen to the whole question. Pause. Then answer.
- Answer only the question asked, then stop talking.
- "Yes," "no," "I don't know," "I don't remember" and "I don't understand the question" are complete answers.
- Estimate only when you have a basis. Never guess.
- Don't explain why you don't remember, and don't apologize.
- Listen for "is it fair to say" and for questions with a hidden premise. Answer in your own words.
- Ask to see any document you're asked about, and read all of it.
- On damages, say all you honestly can, and keep the list open ("the ones I can think of right now").
- If your lawyer starts talking, stop.
- Take a break when you need one, but answer the pending question first.
- Never argue. Never joke. Nothing is off the record.
- When it's over, leave.
Frequently asked questions
When should I prepare my client for a deposition? Hold the full briefing in person a few days before, with time to review prior discovery responses and run a short mock examination. Then repeat the essentials, especially listen, think and take your time, on the morning of the deposition. A briefing given in the hallway five minutes before the start is too late.
Can I tell my client what to say at a deposition? No. You can explain the process, review the documents and prior testimony, discuss the issues and practice the form of answering. You cannot supply facts or encourage false testimony (ABA Model Rule of Professional Conduct 3.4(b)). The client answers in their own words, from their own memory.
Is a deposition preparation session privileged? Your communications with your client are privileged, and a written briefing you give the client is privileged too. Documents the client uses to refresh their memory, before or during the deposition, may have to be produced (Fed. R. Evid. 612; Cal. Evid. Code § 771), so choose them with care.
How long does a deposition last? In federal court, a deposition is limited to one day of seven hours unless the parties stipulate or the court orders otherwise (Fed. R. Civ. P. 30(d)(1)). California generally limits a witness deposition to seven hours of total testimony, with exceptions (Cal. Code Civ. Proc. § 2025.290). Check your forum's rules and any order in your case.
How TrialBase helps
Preparing a client is easier when you know the file cold: every statement the client has made, every record the defense will use, and where the two disagree. TrialBase reads the whole case file. Attack My Case reads it the way defense counsel will, looking for the gap in treatment, the prior complaint in the history, or the report that doesn't match the testimony, and cites each one to the page. After the deposition, TrialBase drafts the deposition summary and the trial testimony outline, each line cited to the transcript's page and line, so you find the problems before trial and not on cross. If your client is representing themselves or you want a plain-English handout, see our companion guide, How to Prepare for Your Own Deposition.