How to Prepare for an Independent Medical Exam (IME) in a Personal Injury Case
What the defense medical exam is really for, what happens in the room, what to say and not say, your rights to have a lawyer present and to record the exam, and what your attorney should do before and after.
· TrialBase
If you have filed an injury claim, the other side will probably ask a doctor of its choosing to examine you. Insurers call it an "independent medical exam," or IME. Lawyers often call it what it is: a defense medical exam. The doctor is hired and paid by the defense. The report they write goes to the insurance adjuster and defense counsel, and it can change what your case settles for. If the case goes to trial, the doctor will likely testify.
A defense exam is not a normal doctor visit, and it is not something to fear. It goes well when you know what it is for, tell the truth completely and consistently, and know your rights. This guide is for injured people and the lawyers who prepare them.
This is general information, not legal advice. The rules for defense exams vary by state and between state and federal court. Your lawyer will tell you which apply to you.
What the exam is for
The doctor has been asked to answer questions for the defense: whether you were injured, whether the incident caused your injuries, whether your treatment was reasonable, whether you still have symptoms, and what care you will need in the future. Some examiners are fair. Some write reports that reliably favor the side that hires them. Either way, the doctor is not your doctor. They will not treat you, and nothing you say is confidential. Everything said in the room can end up in the report.
Assume you are being observed from the moment you arrive. That includes how you walk in from the parking lot, how you sit in the waiting room, how you get on and off the exam table, how you take your shoes off, and how you leave. Inconsistency between what you report and how you move is exactly what the report will look for.
What happens in the room
Most physical exams follow the same two steps.
The history. The doctor, or an assistant, asks about you and your injury:
- Personal background: name, age, occupation and the like.
- How you were hurt: a brief, general description is enough. "I was rear-ended while stopped at a red light." "I slipped on a wet floor in a grocery store." The doctor is there to examine injuries, not to decide who was at fault. Detailed accounts of the accident are for your deposition, where the other side asks under oath with your lawyer present, not for a medical exam where a careless phrase can become an admission about fault.
- Your injuries: every part of the body that was hurt, including injuries that have since healed. This is the time for full detail. Months may have passed since the incident, so refresh your memory beforehand.
- Your pain: describe it for each part of your body, as specifically as you can: where it is, what it feels like, what makes it worse, how it has changed.
- Your treatment: hospital stays, doctors and therapists, surgeries and injections, how often you have been seen, and whether you are still in treatment. Know the basics well enough to give reasonable estimates.
- Your current complaints: "How are you now?" is the most important question in the exam. Describe every symptom and limitation you still have: at work, at home, with sleep, with family.
- Prior injuries and conditions: answer truthfully. The defense already has, or will get, your prior medical records. A prior back problem you disclose is a fact your lawyer can deal with. A prior back problem you deny is a credibility problem that can sink the case.
The physical exam. The doctor examines the areas you said were injured, looking for scarring, swelling, muscle wasting and discoloration. They test range of motion by asking you to bend, turn and twist, feel for muscle spasm and tenderness, and may test strength, reflexes and sensation. Some doctors also do a general exam to look for other conditions that could explain your symptoms. Wear clothing that is easy to move in and to take off; you may be asked to change into a gown.
Many examiners also run tests designed to check whether a patient's responses are consistent. Some of them check for exaggeration. The single best protection is simple: do each movement honestly, to the point where it actually hurts or you actually cannot go further, and say so.
What to say, and what not to say
Do:
- Tell the truth, completely. Report every symptom, even ones that seem minor or embarrassing. If you leave something out, the report will say you never mentioned it.
- Be consistent. Your account should match what you told your own doctors, your interrogatory answers and your deposition. If something has changed, say what changed and when.
- Describe, don't diagnose. "My lower back aches all day and shoots pain down my left leg when I sit for more than twenty minutes" is better than "I have sciatica." Give diagnoses as what you were told: "My surgeon said it was a herniated disc."
- Give your best effort on every test, and say clearly when something hurts or when you can't do it.
- Be polite, even if the doctor is brusque or seems skeptical. Some examiners are cold. Some suggest that your injuries are minor or that you should be better by now. Don't argue and don't be discouraged. The doctor's attitude in the room does not decide your case.
Don't:
- Don't exaggerate. Overstated pain or an exaggerated limp will be written down and used against you, and a jury will not forgive it.
- Don't minimize. "I'm fine, thanks" in response to "How are you?" can end up in the report as "patient states he is fine." Answer accurately.
- Don't guess. If you don't know a date or a number, say so, or give a reasonable estimate and call it one.
- Don't discuss fault, your lawyer, settlement or the lawsuit. None of it is medical, and all of it can be misquoted.
- Don't volunteer opinions about other doctors. Criticism of a treating doctor helps only the defense.
- Don't open up because the doctor is friendly. A warm examiner is still hired by the other side. Answer the questions asked, fully and accurately, and leave it there.
- Don't fill out paperwork beyond basic identification without asking your lawyer. Intake questionnaires can go well beyond what the exam is allowed to cover. Many lawyers object to them or limit them in advance.
Your rights: who can be in the room, and recording
This is where state law matters most.
In California, a defendant in a personal injury case may demand one physical exam of the plaintiff without a court order, as long as it is not painful, protracted or intrusive and takes place within 75 miles of the plaintiff's home (Cal. Code Civ. Proc. § 2032.220). Your attorney, or someone your attorney authorizes in writing, may attend and observe a physical exam and may record by audio everything said to or by you during the exam (Cal. Code Civ. Proc. § 2032.510(a)). The observer may not participate in or disrupt the exam. But if the examiner goes beyond what was agreed or ordered, or becomes abusive, the observer may suspend the exam so the court can decide (§ 2032.510(d)). A mental exam requires a court order or a stipulation (§ 2032.310). Your attorney generally may not attend it, but it may be audio recorded (§ 2032.530).
In federal court, a medical exam requires a court order on a showing of good cause, or an agreement between the parties (Fed. R. Civ. P. 35). Most federal courts do not allow observers or recordings unless there are special circumstances, such as a child plaintiff or a need for an interpreter.
Other states differ. Some allow observers or video. Others leave it to the judge. Ask your lawyer what the demand or order in your case allows, how long the exam may last, and which tests are permitted.
For lawyers: before and after the exam
Before:
- Read the demand or order closely. Check the date, place, examiner, specialty, time limit and the tests to be performed. Object promptly to anything beyond what the rules allow.
- Send an observer, where allowed, and record. A record of what was actually said and done is the best answer to a report that misstates the history or the exam.
- Prepare the client with the records, not a script. Go over the treatment history, prior injuries and current complaints using the medical chronology, so the client's account is complete and matches the records. Remind the client that prior injuries come out anyway.
- Address forms in advance. Decide what written intake the client will complete, if any, and tell the examiner's office.
After:
- Debrief the same day. Ask the client to write down when they arrived, when the exam started and ended, how long the doctor personally spent with them, what tests were done, and what was said. The examiner's report will be measured against those notes and the recording.
- Get the report. In California, the plaintiff may demand a copy of the examiner's report. Doing so entitles the defense to receive, in exchange, the plaintiff's existing reports of examinations of the same condition (Cal. Code Civ. Proc. §§ 2032.610, 2032.640). Weigh that trade before you make the demand.
- Compare the report line by line against the recording, the client's notes and the medical records: misstated history, tests the report describes that were never performed, an exam that took twelve minutes but reads like an hour. These are the cross-examination points that matter to a jury.
Frequently asked questions
Do I have to go to an independent medical exam? If you are the plaintiff in a personal injury case and the demand or court order is proper, generally yes. Refusing can lead to a court order and sanctions. If the date, place or scope is a problem, tell your lawyer right away. Objections usually have to be made promptly.
Can I bring someone with me to an IME? It depends on where your case is. In California, your attorney or their written designee may attend a physical exam and record the conversation by audio. In federal court, observers are usually not allowed without a court order. Ask your lawyer before bringing anyone, even a family member.
How long does an IME take? Often less than an hour, sometimes much less. Note the actual times. The length of the exam can matter later.
Will the IME doctor treat me or tell me the results? No. The doctor examines you for the defense and writes a report for the defense. Keep seeing your own doctors.
Can I get a copy of the IME report? In California, yes, by demand. But making the demand entitles the other side to receive your existing reports of the same condition in exchange. Your lawyer will decide whether and when to ask.
What is an independent medical exam (IME) in a personal injury case? An exam of the injured person by a doctor chosen and paid by the defense or the insurer, to evaluate the injuries, their cause, the treatment and the prognosis. Despite the name, the doctor works for the other side.
What should I wear to an IME? Comfortable clothes that are easy to move in and to take off. You may be asked to change into a gown. Wear what you would normally wear, and don't bring braces or devices you don't usually use.
What should I bring to an IME? A photo ID, the appointment letter, your glasses or hearing aids, and anything else your lawyer asks you to bring. Don't bring medical records, notes or a diary unless your lawyer tells you to.
What if the IME doctor asks how the accident happened? Give a brief, general description, such as "I was rear-ended while stopped at a light." The exam is about your injuries, not about who was at fault.
What if part of the exam hurts? Say so at the time, clearly, and stop at the point where it hurts. In California, an attorney observer can suspend an exam that goes beyond what was agreed or ordered. Tell your lawyer afterward about anything that went beyond what you expected.
Can the IME be video recorded? In California, the statute gives the right to an audio recording of a physical exam, not a video recording; video generally requires an agreement or a court order. In federal court, recording usually requires a court order. Other states vary.
Is an IME the same as a workers' compensation QME? No. Workers' compensation has its own exam system with its own rules (in California, Qualified Medical Evaluators and Agreed Medical Evaluators). This guide covers defense exams in civil injury lawsuits.
What happens after the IME? The doctor writes a report for the defense. It often shapes the settlement offer, and if the case goes to trial, the doctor usually testifies as the defense's medical expert. Your lawyer will compare the report against the recording, your notes and your medical records.
Should I keep seeing my own doctors after the IME? Yes. Continue the treatment your own doctors recommend. A gap in treatment after the exam can be used to argue that you recovered.